Comparing and Ranking in Science when both Quantity and Quality Matter
_____________________________________________________________________
A picture: dominance network among the top 112 US universities
(All rights reserved - performed by A. Lahatte)
(weak dominance dyadic relations, transitive dominance relations are omitted, all publications are considered, impact is measured with citations)
______________________________________________________________________
Ranking of top US research universities
Interdisciplinary based rankings (all disciplines are included)
• Ranking when all publications are considered (phi = 1) and when direct citations (3 years window) are used to account for publications impact. All disciplines
• Ranking when all
publications are considered (phi = 1) and when the direct impact factor
of the journal (3 years window) is used to account for publications
impact. All disciplines
• Ranking when all
publications are considered (phi = 1) and when the relative impact
factor of the journal (3 years window) is used to account for
publications impact. All disciplines
•
Ranking when only publications in the top ten
percent of their discipline are considered (phi = 0.1)
and when
the direct citations (3
years window) is used to account
for publications impact. All
disciplines
•
Ranking when only publications in the top ten
percent of their discipline are considered (phi = 0.1)
and when
the direct impact factor of the journal (3 years window) is used to account
for publications impact. All disciplines
• Ranking when only publications in the top ten percent of their discipline are considered (phi = 0.1) and when the relative impact factor of the journal (3 years window) is used to account for publications impact. All disciplines
Disciplinary
based rankings (rankings are produced for each of the 8 large
disciplines considered)
•
Ranking when all publications are considered (phi = 1) and when direct
citations (3 years window) are used to account for publications
impact. (Fund.
biology, Medicine,
App. bio & ecol
, Chemistry,
Physics, Sc. of the univ., Eng. sciences,
Mathematics)
• Ranking when all
publications are considered (phi = 1) and when the direct impact factor
of the journal (3 years window) is used to account for publications
impact. (Fund. biology,
Medicine,
App. bio &
ecol
, Chemistry,
Physics,
Sc. of the univ.,
Eng. sciences,
Mathematics)
• Ranking when all publications are considered (phi = 1) and when the relative impact factor of the journal (3 years window) is used to account for publications impact. (Fund. biology, Medicine, App. bio & ecol , Chemistry, Physics, Sc. of the univ., Eng. sciences, Mathematics) • Ranking when only publications in the top ten percent of their discipline are considered (phi = 0.1) and when direct citations (3 years window) are used to account for publications impact. (Fund. biology, Medicine, App. bio & ecol , Chemistry, Physics, Sc. of the univ., Eng. sciences, Mathematics)
• Ranking when only publications in the top ten percent of their discipline are considered (phi = 0.1) and when the direct impact factor of the journal (3 years window) is used to account for publications impact. (Fund. biology, Medicine, App. bio & ecol , Chemistry, Physics, Sc. of the univ., Eng. sciences, Mathematics)
• Ranking when only publications in the top ten percent of their discipline are considered (phi = 0.1) and when the relative impact factor of the journal (3 years window) is used to account for publications impact.(Fund. biology, Medicine, App. bio & ecol , Chemistry, Physics, Sc. of the univ., Eng. sciences, Mathematics)
______________________________________________________________________
Ranking of top world wide
departments in economics
• Ranking of top
economic departments (all registered scholars in the departments are
considered). Econ department
• Ranking of top economic departments when only scholars in the top ten percent cited are considered. Econ departments